Chris Lisinski/SHNS
Price report is newest piece of proof of system beneath heavy pressure
STATE HOUSE, BOSTON, MARCH 13, 2025…..Warning that the state’s well being care system is “falling aside,” the Senate’s level particular person on the subject mentioned Thursday that she needs to rein in for-profit and personal fairness entities in addition to give regulators extra muscle to manage rising prices.
Policymakers and well being care trade leaders gathered for an annual listening to concerning the so-called benchmark state authorities units as a purpose for affordable well being care spending development, the place they unpacked new knowledge that confirmed well being care bills surged at a near-record price in 2023.
Kicking off the occasion, Sen. Cindy Friedman didn’t mince phrases.
“We hear a couple of system in disaster. We’re past that. It’s now falling aside,” mentioned Friedman, who has co-chaired the Legislature’s Well being Care Financing Committee since 2019. “It’s crucial for us to dig into which companies and entities are siphoning essentially the most well being care {dollars} and returning the least worth, in addition to those who supply extra worth at a decrease value. It’s time for the state, together with the administration and Legislature, to take daring steps to rein in prices and refocus the well being care system on the affected person and the supply of high quality care to these sufferers, relatively than cash and revenue.”
The Middle for Well being Info and Evaluation reported Wednesday that well being care spending in Massachusetts grew at an 8.6% price from 2022 to 2023, greater than twice the three.6% benchmark and the second-highest annual improve since state watchdogs started monitoring the info a decade in the past.
CHIA researchers dubbed the 2023 development price “unsustainable,” and mentioned the most important drivers had been elevated pharmacy spending and new MassHealth supplemental funds to hospitals.
After listening to a number of hours of testimony concerning the knowledge and requires change from main trade stakeholders, Friedman mentioned she expects the Senate to “take one other move” at a number of the subjects, like personal fairness, that featured in well being care debates final time period.
“We nonetheless have this big problem of personal fairness and for-profit in well being care, and it’s driving loads of this, loads of these prices,” she advised the Information Service. “We’re going to do this, after which we’re going to assault main care once more and the prior authorization items, which is de facto driving individuals out of the enterprise as a result of they will’t present the care that they skilled for.”
“We’re going to return a second time, a 3rd time, and push these as a result of we actually imagine that they’ll have a serious impression on care and high quality,” she added.
The Legislature and Gov. Maura Healey late final yr enacted a pair of recent legal guidelines, one aimed toward reining in prescription drug prices and the opposite designed to enhance hospital monetary oversight. (CHIA’s newest annual spending report solely covers 2023, so the brand new legal guidelines haven’t but affected the topline knowledge.)
Beacon Hill created the benchmark course of in a 2012 value containment regulation. The determine is a goal for spending development, not a cap, and regulators don’t mechanically impose penalties when prices surpass the benchmark.
Friedman, an Arlington Democrat, mentioned the info produced annually for the reason that course of began have “gotten higher and higher.”
“There’s info on this report that’s invaluable,” she mentioned of CHIA’s newest findings. “I believe what we haven’t accomplished is give the [Health Policy Commission] — and, to some extent, the Division of Insurance coverage — the instruments to begin to convey these prices down. I believe that’s actually the subsequent step that we’ve got to take a look at very rigorously: how can we empower them within the work that they do to assist us convey these prices down?”
Leaders of the HPC have lengthy requested Beacon Hill to present the company extra enamel and muscle to implement spending development limits.
Friedman’s counterpart within the Home, Rep. John Garden, equally mentioned Massachusetts is “at a pivotal second in well being care,” particularly as fears swirl concerning the Trump administration slicing federal funding for Medicaid or different packages.
“The well being care sector is going through immense uncertainty and frustration, domestically and nationally. We’re grappling with the Trump administration’s fiscal coverage upheaval. We could moderately count on that Massachusetts will see a discount in funding for essential well being care companies, a blow to our residents and our economic system,” Garden, a Watertown Democrat, mentioned on the listening to. “However this isn’t a momentary shake. The generational well being disaster attributable to COVID-19 uncovered and exacerbated a large number of long-standing challenges, challenges that proceed to have an effect on our well being care system at present, from rising inflation to shifting patterns in care, ongoing provide chain disruptions and workforce shortages.”
CHIA discovered that the statewide common premium elevated 6 p.c in 2023 to $631 per member per 30 days.
Researchers mentioned pharmaceutical spending, new MassHealth supplemental funds to hospitals, and care offered in hospital outpatient settings — that are usually cheaper than inpatient admissions however pricier than doctor places of work — had been main drivers of the general development.
A number of listening to attendees urged lawmakers and the HPC to coach their deal with the pharmaceutical trade. Alex Sheff, senior coverage and authorities relations director at Well being Look after All, mentioned retaining spending development near the benchmark “has to begin with reining in prescription drug prices.”
“With out value constraints on suppliers within the pharmaceutical trade, well being plans can not make well being care extra reasonably priced to your constituents,” added Lora Pellegrini, president of the Massachusetts Affiliation of Well being Plans group that represents insurers.
Nobody from the pharmaceutical sector spoke at Thursday’s listening to, however Stami Williams, director for public affairs at trade group PhRMA, mentioned in a press release that CHIA’s report “doesn’t paint an entire image.”
“There are a number of components that may affect spending on medicines that this report overlooks, together with the variety of medicines prescribed to sufferers,” Williams mentioned. “We are going to proceed to supply options to lawmakers that decrease prices on the pharmacy and defend entry to the medicines sufferers want.”
Friedman famous early within the proceedings that completely different figures throughout the well being care panorama are inclined to level fingers at each other.
“I’ve heard from suppliers and well being methods that reimbursement charges are too low, from well being plans saying that reimbursement charges and pharmacy spending are too excessive, from impartial pharmacies telling me they’re fighting low reimbursement charges and clawbacks, from [pharmacy benefit managers] that say that impartial pharmacies are steady and they don’t claw again claims, from pharmaceutical producers saying reductions to 340B-covered entities are too excessive, and from group well being facilities and security web hospitals telling me they can not function with out full 340B margins, and so forth,” Friedman mentioned.
“Now there’s loads of nuance to those statements, they usually can all be true to an extent, however it begs the query of the place our well being care {dollars} are actually going if everybody says they don’t have a sufficiently big slice of the pie,” she added.
The sharp rise in well being care spending got here as Bay Staters struggled with rising pocketbook stress on many different fronts. CHIA analysts crunched knowledge from a number of sources, and located that the 9.7% development in wages and salaries in Massachusetts from 2021 to 2023 lagged not solely value adjustments for well being care premiums but in addition the expansion in center-based little one care costs (15.8%), New England housing bills (19%) and New England meals bills (26.8%) in the identical span.
Eileen McAnneny, president of the Employer Coalition of Well being, urged policymakers to weigh well being care prices “within the broader context” of different components affecting companies, together with vitality costs and unemployment advantages.
“I simply ask: we are able to’t settle for these double digit well being care prices yr over yr after which wring our arms when well being care prices go up,” McAnneny mentioned. Now we have to truly do one thing, and I’d recommend with urgency.”